« Back

Citizen Media Handbook - Chapter 11 - Don't try to be an Alien

Some traditional journalists pretend they are objective. They may even think they really are, as if they were aliens just landed on the planet Earth.

But the truth is that as journalists we can have integrity (we don't distort, we're factual), but we can't be unbiased. In chapter 1 we gave some examples of the institiutional bias of the traditiional media. Lots of personal factors influence how we report a story, our class, ethnicity, gender, education, politics, etc. Even if we were extra-terrestrials, we would arrive on the planet with a set of assumptions about the earthlings we were reporting on.

Here's an example of how different journalists might report exactly the same story:

The actual visionOntv report:

1. LONG-SHOT of house facade with banner "Fighting another Barclays Repossession".

VO: Homes and businesses are being repossessed all over London. This one was taken back by Barclays Bank, who then left it empty for at least 2 years.

2. MID-SHOT of group of squatters and supporters at gate of house.

VO: Around 2 months ago a group of homeless people occupied the building and took it as their home.

3. CLOSE-UP sign on fence "Free Tea and Biscuits (Also for Bailiffs)"

VO: Today they and supporters and friends are in front of the property to prevent access to the bailiffs and stop this first attempt at eviction.

How an anarchist news magazine might report:

1. LONG-SHOT of house facade with banner "Fighting another Barclays Repossession".

VO: When Barclays Bank repossessed this property and then left it empty for 2 years, the only answer was crowbars at dawn.

2. MID-SHOT of group of squatters and supporters at gate of house.

VO: When bailiffs came to evict, they were met by a local posse.

3. CLOSE-UP sign on fence "Free Tea and Biscuits (Also for Bailiffs)"

VO: For more information on how to defend squats in your local area, go to.....

How the BBC might report:

1. LONG-SHOT of house facade with banner "Fighting another Barclays Repossession".

VO: Another week, another building in East London occupied by squatters.

2. MID-SHOT of group of squatters and supporters at gate of house.

VO: The government says they are invading people's homes. The squatters say they are occupying a property left empty for some time.

3. CLOSE-UP sign on fence "Free Tea and Biscuits (Also for Bailiffs)"

VO: Owners Barclays Bank told us they have no choice but to go to the expense of eviction to protect their property.

How Fox News might report it:

1. LONG-SHOT of house facade with banner "Fighting another Barclays Repossession".

VO: Yet another property invaded by squatters in London, England.

2. MID-SHOT of group of squatters and supporters at gate of house.

VO: A phenomenon that has become a plague for home-owners across the United Kingdom.

3. CLOSE-UP sign on fence "Free Tea and Biscuits (Also for Bailiffs)"

VO: Harmless layabouts or dangerous anarchists? You decide.

Remember: Be accurate. Have integrity. Be a trustworthy news source.

0 Attachments
1609 Views
Average (0 Votes)
The average rating is 0.0 stars out of 5.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.